LaserDisc Database
https://forum.lddb.com/

What would be an upgrade?
https://forum.lddb.com/viewtopic.php?f=23&t=1566
Page 1 of 1

Author:  Guest [ 20 Aug 2012, 22:52 ]
Post subject:  What would be an upgrade?

Hello and greetings,

I'm sure you get similar questions daily (and I admit to have lurked here before as a guest) but I felt I needed to ask someone this question, because I felt I was just getting more and more confused while pondering on my own. I made a very similar thread on another LD-forum (Retroflix) and was recommended the CLD-2950 but I thought I'd ask here as well.

I've had my first player for what very soon will be a year. It's a Pioneer CLD-V2800 that I scored for "cheap" through eBay and I have been thinking of making an upgrade. But there are so many players out there that I just become :crazy:

What I'm wondering is:

1) Where in the hierarchy does this belong? I know it's an industrial player but does it belong in the low or mid-range?

2) What player would be a noticeable upgrade (and are there other good brands beside Pioneer)?
Double side playback would be nice, CLD trick play would be even nicer and optical out could be an added bonus :P

3) Sort of related, are the older players any good? Specifically, If used with a good comb filter and/or scaler?

I want to state again, I'm not looking for the "best" player out there, just something that would be better. Elites and Japanese import units will probably be ruled out, sadly, and I don't want to pay extra for some old on-board Y/C separation I do not need. My main concern is picture noise - most of my discs are okay, but some older ones are pretty grainy. When reading about LD players online I stumbled over this quote:

Quote:
The consumer age seems to be divided between Pre-Digital Noise Reduction and Post-Digital Noise Reduction.
What I mean by that is the older players, like the CLD-3080 and the Elite 95 and the Elite LD S2, had to rely on good processing to put out
a nice, solid, stable noise-free or noise-reduced picture.
After digital noise reduction was developed fully and was in players like the CLD D703, D704, Elite 79, Elite 99, the native picture the
players put out were terrible for chroma and luminence noise. You HAD to rely on some mixture of both types(chroma and luminence) of noise
reduction to get a nice, smooth, noise-free picture.

I remember when I had a D704.... for older pan and scan titles like Pretty Woman, I would have to put DNR on full blown max. On better
produced laserdiscs I could settle for a mid-point setting.
With my Elite 95, I can rely on the native output for a nice clean stable picture.

To me, it sounds like the older players should provide a better, less digitized image. But since I'm looking to cutting out the noise, I'm not sure that is what I want. :shifty:
I see many LD players show up on eBay but I find it hard to know if they are any good, especially in comparison to what I already have, even with the help of the Laserdisc Archive.
Sorry if this post seems a bit vague and unfocused, I should've hit the sack a while ago :wave:

Author:  naiaru [ 20 Aug 2012, 23:59 ]
Post subject:  Re: What would be an upgrade?

Well first off, is PAL playback important to you?

Author:  Guest [ 21 Aug 2012, 07:25 ]
Post subject:  Re: What would be an upgrade?

naiaru wrote:
Well first off, is PAL playback important to you?


Not at all. I think I was recommended an NTSC/PAL-player because it seemed a popular player over at the Retroflix forums, which is a british site. I'm more after japanese releases than anything so having PAL support would be mostly unnecessary, I'm afraid.

Edit: Also, things like AC3, surround and the like isn't important - I'm fine with stereo as my setup doesn't allow for more than that at the moment, either.

Author:  cpix [ 21 Aug 2012, 19:01 ]
Post subject:  Re: What would be an upgrade?

oh, so many to choose from, could I ask which price level you are targeted at? =)

Author:  Guest [ 21 Aug 2012, 19:54 ]
Post subject:  Re: What would be an upgrade?

cpix wrote:
oh, so many to choose from, could I ask which price level you are targeted at? =)

Err, I will admit to not wanting to spend too much. Maybe about an $300 top, but if possible somewhere between $150 and $225. :oops: I want to remember spending about 100$ on my current, and most of that was shipping to Europe from the US.
Hence why I ruled out the more exclusive players in my first post :shifty:

Author:  naiaru [ 21 Aug 2012, 21:15 ]
Post subject:  Re: What would be an upgrade?

ji-l87 wrote:
cpix wrote:
oh, so many to choose from, could I ask which price level you are targeted at? =)

Err, I will admit to not wanting to spend too much. Maybe about an $300 top, but if possible somewhere between $150 and $225. :oops: I want to remember spending about 100$ on my current, and most of that was shipping to Europe from the US.
Hence why I ruled out the more exclusive players in my first post :shifty:

I'd recommend the Panasonic LX-600 or LX-900 (if you can find one). They are comparable to Pioneer's 703-based players, but with much lower overall noise. Not to mention they tend to be much cheaper (although their reputation has been going up as of late, so that might not be the case indefinitely). I got my LX-600 for about $90 total (including shipping) and it blew my 703 away. (and then someone else bought it for $280)

Author:  Guest [ 21 Aug 2012, 21:40 ]
Post subject:  Re: What would be an upgrade?

naiaru wrote:
I'd recommend the Panasonic LX-600 or LX-900 (if you can find one). They are comparable to Pioneer's 703-based players, but with much lower overall noise. Not to mention they tend to be much cheaper (although their reputation has been going up as of late, so that might not be the case indefinitely). I got my LX-600 for about $90 total (including shipping) and it blew my 703 away. (and then someone else bought it for $280)


Thanks, I've been keeping my eyes out for 600 & 900 but none seem to be floating around at the moment. Any more recommendations? :D (The more the better)
I saw a Pioneer CLD-D503 on eBay as well as an CLD-D606 (though it ended, doubt it sold tho'-seen it before), any opinions on those?

Author:  naiaru [ 21 Aug 2012, 23:37 ]
Post subject:  Re: What would be an upgrade?

ji-l87 wrote:
naiaru wrote:
I'd recommend the Panasonic LX-600 or LX-900 (if you can find one). They are comparable to Pioneer's 703-based players, but with much lower overall noise. Not to mention they tend to be much cheaper (although their reputation has been going up as of late, so that might not be the case indefinitely). I got my LX-600 for about $90 total (including shipping) and it blew my 703 away. (and then someone else bought it for $280)


Thanks, I've been keeping my eyes out for 600 & 900 but none seem to be floating around at the moment. Any more recommendations? :D (The more the better)
I saw a Pioneer CLD-D503 on eBay as well as an CLD-D606 (though it ended, doubt it sold tho'-seen it before), any opinions on those?

Those two (CLD-D503 and CLD-D606) are mid-tier players. They're all right, but if you're budget is really in the 150-300 range, you should skip right on past them. I hear good things about the LD-V8000, perhaps that's worth a look.

Author:  Guest [ 22 Aug 2012, 07:39 ]
Post subject:  Re: What would be an upgrade?

naiaru wrote:
ji-l87 wrote:
Thanks, I've been keeping my eyes out for 600 & 900 but none seem to be floating around at the moment. Any more recommendations? :D (The more the better)
I saw a Pioneer CLD-D503 on eBay as well as an CLD-D606 (though it ended, doubt it sold tho'-seen it before), any opinions on those?

Those two (CLD-D503 and CLD-D606) are mid-tier players. They're all right, but if you're budget is really in the 150-300 range, you should skip right on past them. I hear good things about the LD-V8000, perhaps that's worth a look.


Oh yeah, that one I remember reading about. Seems like an interesting player, too bad it doesn't have autoflip. :problem: Still, does feature CLV trick play and that's one of my most sought after features. Haven't seen too many around, however. But I'll keep looking, thanks for the recommendations so far :thumbup:

Edit: How's the V6000A in comparison to the V8000?

Author:  naiaru [ 23 Aug 2012, 02:30 ]
Post subject:  Re: What would be an upgrade?

rixrex is selling a Panasonic LX-600 here. PM him and see if you can get him to ship to Sweden.

Author:  Guest [ 23 Aug 2012, 10:43 ]
Post subject:  Re: What would be an upgrade?

naiaru wrote:
rixrex is selling a Panasonic LX-600 here. PM him and see if you can get him to ship to Sweden.


That I did, we'll see how this goes. Interesting list of players on there :)

Edit: It's on hold at the moment.

Edit edit: Bought it!

Page 1 of 1 All times are UTC [ DST ]
Powered by phpBB © 2000, 2002, 2005, 2007 phpBB Group
http://www.phpbb.com/