There's also the Image discs all with commentary by Paul Mandell:

Citizen Kane (1941) [I6002]
King Kong (1933) [I6003]
Mighty Joe Young (1949) [I5032]
Hunchback of Notre Dame, The (1939) [I5034]

I don't think any of these were ever released on DVD.

Did I not see those on the list or did you recently add them?

Perhaps two more:

Brute Force (1947) [RGL9506]
I know Criterion used a different commentary for their DVD release.

Tom Sawyer (1973) [ML101863]

I used to have to have a copy of highlander 10th anniversary edition on ld which I'm pretty sure had a different commentary to my blue ray copy

I used to have to have a copy of highlander 10th anniversary edition on ld which I'm pretty sure had a different commentary to my blue ray copy

Updated. Thanks!

TLK

Just wanted to point out that Gornick was not on the Elite CAV Box Set commentary track, but Christine Romero is along with George and Savini. Gornick's only commentary appearances are on DVD releases of Martin (Lion's Gate) and Creepshow 2: Special Edition (Anchor Bay). Not trying to be a jerk, just correcting some info.

Yes it does, that Elite commentary was never ported to any other release/format.

The Special Edition Leatherface: Texas Chainsaw Massacre 3 laserdisc has two commentary tracks, and I believe the DVD only has one. From what I understand, the DVD track is basically the two LD tracks (which feature a bunch of the cast and crew) cut and pasted together to make one track.

The back cover of the Scream laserdisc says it has commentary by director, Wes Craven, but does not mention that writer, Kevin Williamson, is also on the commentary. I've always assumed that the commentary on the DVD releases are different, because the laserdisc is the unrated director's cut while the DVD releases (all of them, I believe) are the theatrical cut. I have not confirmed that the commentaries are different, I just assume that they are because they would be commenting on different versions of the film.

The Lawnmower Man: Special Edition

This LD's commentary must be different from the one on DVD. The LD is a longer director's version while the R1 DVD only has the shorter theatrical cut.

I have no idea if the DVD commentary is simply an edit of the LD commentary, or a totally different recording. (I haven't actually listened to the LD commentary yet, and don't have the DVD to compare.)

Yes it does, that Elite commentary was never ported to any other release/format.

I don't see Tales From the Hood on the list. It has a track with director Rusty Cundieff that is not on the long OOP HBO DVD.