Hi Julien & Everyone,
I've got another glitch in the system to report. It is related to the level of severity when reporting laser rot on a title. I have discussed this a long time ago with Julien, but have never talked about it here in the time since The Forum has existed. This problem seems to be limited to Hong Kong and Taiwanese titles, which as many of you will know, I have a lot of in my collection. Since many of these titles were pressed at the Japanese plants, it is not a problem which has come up frequently. However, I have encountered a few titles from these countries with more than a mild degree of rot. The specific examples I could give of this are the Hong Kong releases of Mad Stylist, Stephen King's The Shining ('97), and the newly validated Poison Ivy 3: The New Seduction. I have seen copies of all three of these with what I would classify as "strong" rot. When I click on the link to report rot on one of these titles, I am able to input the level as 4/5 stars. It appears with 4 stars next to the title on my rot report page. However, when I go to the listing page for the title, it only shows that "light" rot was reported. Also, when I go back to my rot report page, the system has changed the rating level to "light" rot (1/5 stars). I have tried several times to change the level back to 4/5 stars, but I can't get the system to accept anything but "light" 1/5 rot level on any of them. Has anyone else noticed this problem
when reporting rotted titles? Perhaps not, as I am pretty sure it is NOT affecting U.S. or Japanese releases
. I'm unsure about China, Singapore, or Malaysia, since I have not encountered any discs from these countries with anything greater than "light" 1/5 level rot. There is certainly something strange going on in the rot report section of the site, and I hope that this demon
can be tracked down and exorcised by Father Julien
, preferably before Halloween is over!
Best Regards,
David